Skip to Content

Neighbors Bank Reviews

Unedited reviews from borrowers nationwide

6,410

Total Customer Reviews

96%

Would recommend Neighbors Bank

4.7 out of 5

Average Satisfaction Rating

    Showing all 6,410 unfiltered reviews

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Indiana Would Recommend

    They were very kind and patient with me. Talk me through a lot of things I didn't understand. Kept in contact with myself and my real estate agent. Gave me time to get all the paperwork together. I work very well with them. I would recommend them to anyone want a USDA loan.

    Joshua Falke, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Joshua Falke

    NMLS#2181237

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Jan 20, 2026

    Ashley Harris, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Ashley Harris

    NMLS#1106948

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Connecticut Would Recommend

    Jan 20, 2026

    Nathan Groves, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Nathan Groves

    NMLS#1096165

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    The entire team I worked with was amazing. Joey mirth , Ashley mirth and last but not least Abbie . These people made what could have been a trying time an easy walk in the park. Amazing job can’t say enough good things !

    Joey Mirth, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Joey Mirth

    NMLS#1965551

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Jan 20, 2026

    Jessica Jamison, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Jamison

    NMLS#1542764

    Loan type: No cash-out refinance

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Wisconsin Would Recommend

    Jan 19, 2026

    Tim Vieck, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Tim Vieck

    NMLS#2181144

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Montana Would Recommend

    Between the app and online platform, it was very easy to stay up to date with our loan process. The team was helpful and understanding.

    Eli Ahn, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Eli Ahn

    NMLS#1864503

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Kentucky Would Recommend

    Over the last couple of months I have been working with Shannon Matlack to purchase my dream home. Shannon is an absolute GEM. She was very responsive to all my needs and had a positive attitude throughout the entire process. I ran into several obstacles along the way (no fault of hers) but she worked diligently to help me resolve them in order to move forward. Anyone who has the opportunity to have her as their loan officer is blessed. She is amazing!!

    Shannon Matlack, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Shannon Matlack

    NMLS#982020

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Illinois Would Recommend

    Jan 18, 2026

    Rob Parham, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Rob Parham

    NMLS#1524830

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Ohio Would Recommend

    Jan 18, 2026

    The two people I dealt with were intelligent and friendly. I was kept informed well every step along the process. The website is easy to navigate too, keeping me updated on the progress and my to do list to expedite matters.

    Derek Wilson, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Derek Wilson

    NMLS#2653342

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in New Jersey Would Recommend

    Jessica and Kathryn were absolutely amazing! They were responsive and explained everything carefully. No hiccups anywhere!

    Jessica Kelly, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Kelly

    NMLS#1450320

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Indiana Would Recommend

    Jan 17, 2026

    Todd Denny, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Todd Denny

    NMLS#2673037

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Oklahoma Would Recommend

    Amazing people to work with. Ashley and alyssa were very very awesome

    Ashley Owens, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Ashley Owens

    NMLS#2653377

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Massachusetts Would Recommend

    Jan 16, 2026

    Christina Jordan, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Christina Jordan

    NMLS#2672750

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in West Virginia Would Recommend

    Marissa, Ashley & Tiffani were an amazing team to work with - They kept me updated on the process, explained all of my loan information well and were overall very kind. I would highly recommend Neighbors Bank, especially as a first time home buyer!

    Marissa Nichols, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Marissa Nichols

    NMLS#902827

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Ohio Would Recommend

    Jan 16, 2026

    Melissa Janke, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Melissa Janke

    NMLS#995505

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Nebraska Would Recommend

    Jan 16, 2026

    Jessica Seek, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Seek

    NMLS#2110132

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 2 out of 5 Stars
    in Tennessee Would Recommend

    Jan 16, 2026

    Very helpful

    Paden Klein, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Paden Klein

    NMLS#2589666

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 2 out of 5 Stars

    Jan 16, 2026

    At first the experience was great. About 3 days before closing more and more things were needed that could have been gone over by underwriting a week beforehand. Because of this our closing date was pushed back by a week. Also the loan officer was hard for our realtor to get ahold of from time to time, customer service was great but in the future I would recommend underwriting getting documents and things they need in a timely manner. Rather then waiting till the last second to need confirmation on payments when my bank statement was sent 3 weeks prior.

    Kaleb, Client Advocate
    Response from Kaleb, Client Advocate :

    Thank you for sharing your experience. I’m glad to hear things started off well and that our customer service team was supportive—but I’m truly sorry for the last-minute requests and communication delays that added stress right before closing.

    You’re absolutely right: document reviews should happen in a timely manner, and communication with your loan officer should be reliable. If there’s anything more I can do or if you’d like to talk further, I’m here to help.

    clientadvocate@neighborsbank.com
    833-919-1229

    Lee Franklin, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Lee Franklin

    NMLS#1990666

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in New Mexico Would Recommend

    There were times, that I thought, would not get the home, because of the different steps it took to complete

    Lee Franklin, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Lee Franklin

    NMLS#1990666

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Virginia Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Travis Seitzinger, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Travis Seitzinger

    NMLS#2673107

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Ohio Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Jessica Seek, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Jessica Seek

    NMLS#2110132

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Ohio Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Bob Anderson, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Bob Anderson

    NMLS#994072

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Vermont Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Christian Gentil, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Christian Gentil

    NMLS#2355963

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Arkansas Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Bentley Stilwell, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Bentley Stilwell

    NMLS#2355453

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Indiana Would Recommend

    The people of neighbor’s bank have been phenomenal.

    Reed Steuber, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Reed Steuber

    NMLS#1842866

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 4 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Ashley Patterson, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Ashley Patterson

    NMLS#2110130

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in South Carolina Would Recommend

    Jan 15, 2026

    Chris Yackley, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chris Yackley

    NMLS#2110129

    Loan type: Purchase

  • 5 out of 5 Stars
    in Missouri Would Recommend

    Chad,mario,and jd really made the experience easy to deal with great team to work with. I would highly recommend you guy's in the future thank you!

    Chad Werner, Loan Officer

    Loan Officer: Chad Werner

    NMLS#1100523

    Loan type: Purchase

Send Your Feedback

We want to hear about your experience with Neighbors Bank!

Send your feedback »

Find the Right Mortgage for You
1,803 families started their quote today.